City Consensus · New York
Dollar Slice in New York
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Dollar Slice in New York below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 5 Cheap Slices in New York
The cheap-slice canon — true $1 slices are nearly extinct, but these standing-counter classics remain the editorial standard.
- #1
Joe's Pizza
Greenwich Village
“Since 1975. The platonic NYC slice — thin, foldable, reliably excellent, and still a universal reference point.”
- #2
2 Bros Pizza
East Village
“The $1-slice flag-bearer that held the line longest; drunk-food canon and a genre unto itself.”
- #3
Scarr's Pizza
Lower East Side
“House-milled flour on a cheap slice — Scarr Pimentel's LES shop elevated the counter slice without leaving the form.”
- #4
Bleecker Street Pizza
West Village
“Nonna Maria and grandma slices that win blind tastings year after year; the West Village locals' pick.”
- #5
Prince Street Pizza
Nolita
“The spicy-pepperoni Sicilian square that launched a thousand imitators; the line outside is the review.”