City Consensus · Baltimore
Italian in Baltimore
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Italian in Baltimore below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 4 Italian in Baltimore
Italian in Baltimore — cross-referenced from the 2025 Best Restaurants Readers' Poll and Baltimore's Best Restaurants 2024.
- #1
Cinghiale
Harbor East
“Baltimore Magazine Best Restaurants 2024: Tony Foreman's Harbor East enoteca-osteria with house-made pastas, imported meats, and a 2025 Readers' Poll Best Wine Program finalist nod.”
- #2
Tagliata
Harbor East
“Baltimore Magazine Best Restaurants 2024: the swank Atlas Restaurant Group Harbor East hit — bold, rich flavors in a crowd-pleasing Italian steakhouse format.”
- #3
La Scala
Little Italy
“2025 Readers' Poll Best Italian Cuisine finalist and a Baltimore Magazine Best Restaurants 2024 pick — the quarter-century Little Italy staple with a rare indoor bocce court and house-made pasta.”
- #4
Frank's Pizza & Pasta
Belair-Edison
“2025 Readers' Poll Best Italian Cuisine winner — the same Belair Road spot that swept the 2025 Best Pizza polls.”