Skip to content

Columbus, OH

For Ice Cream in Columbus, the local food press points to Mardi Gras Homemade Ice Cream, Diamonds Ice Cream, and Ritzy's. Picks from Columbus Underground and 614NOW, updated July 2026.

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Columbus Underground and 614NOW. Updated July 2026.

Mardi Gras Homemade Ice Cream · Northwest Columbus
Mardi Gras pairs familiar chocolate and fruit scoops with Indian flavors such as rajbhog, kesar pista, and mango. The Hard Road shop makes its ice cream in house, giving the freezer case a broad range that rewards mixing a classic favorite with a flavor built from saffron, nuts, or tropical fruit.
Diamonds Ice Cream · Northwest Columbus
Diamonds specializes in Mexican ice cream, fruit drinks, and frozen treats prepared at its Bethel Sawmill shop. The rotating case moves from creamy standards to bright fruit flavors, while paletas and aguas frescas widen the options. It is a useful stop when a scoop and something refreshing both sound right.
Ritzy's · Clintonville
Ritzy's brings a retro counter format to North High Street, serving burgers alongside a serious house ice cream program. Hand dipped scoops, sundaes, shakes, and seasonal flavors give the dessert side its own identity. The old school room and straightforward service make it easy to linger over a cone.
Laguna Mexican Street Food & Ice Cream · Northwest Columbus
Laguna combines a Mexican street food menu with a dedicated ice cream counter at its Hard Road storefront. The freezer holds colorful fruit and cream flavors that work after tacos or as a visit of their own. Generous scoops and playful combinations give the dessert side more substance than a token add on.
Clown Cones & Confections · Northland
Clown Cones has served Cleveland Avenue with house made ice cream, candy, and confections for decades. The compact shop leans into cheerful nostalgia, with colorful decor and a deep flavor board. Scoops, sundaes, and chocolate treats make it a neighborhood dessert counter with an unusually broad handmade selection.

What’s your #1 Ice Cream in Columbus, OH?

Rank your top five and be the first to set Columbus, OH's local ranking.

More Columbus, OH rankings

Ice Cream in nearby cities