The Record · Madison, WI · Pizza
Pizza in Madison, WI, ranked by the locals who eat there.
Local consensus · Real turnout · No paid placement
Unclaimed
Nobody’s ranked this yet.
Top Tier editorial has a take on pizza in Madison, WI below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have filed theirs.
Editorial picks
Top 3 Pizza in Madison
Top Tier EditorialSourcesIsthmusMadison Magazine
- №1
Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Madison
East Johnson
“Isthmus pick and Madison Magazine 2025 Silver — classic Jersey tomato pie with cheese next to the crust and sauce on top, local sourcing, specialty pies.”
- №2
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - Madison East
Atwood
“Isthmus pick and Madison Magazine 2025 Bronze — Madison institution known for the Fetalicious (spinach and feta) and wide delivery range.”
- №3
Ian’s Pizza Madison | State Street
State Street
“Isthmus pick — famous for the Mac N' Cheese slice and a crust that balances bready flavor with crispiness under inventive toppings.”
Add to the record
Your pizza. On the record.
You just read what Madison, WI has filed. Add your picks — right here on the web — and see where your taste lands.