Milwaukee, WI
For Sandwiches in Milwaukee, the local food press points to Hen's Deli, Donut Monster, and St. Paul Fish Company | Historic Third Ward, Milwaukee. Picks from OnMilwaukee, updated July 2026.
Editor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in OnMilwaukee. Updated July 2026.
Hen's Deli · Walker's Point
Hen's Deli takes a focused approach to sandwiches from its Walker's Point counter. Carefully layered meats, cheeses, vegetables, and sauces turn recognizable deli forms into thoughtful combinations, while the compact menu and casual room make it an easy lunch stop that still feels deliberately crafted.
Donut Monster · Historic Third Ward
Donut Monster uses its from scratch English muffins as the foundation for substantial breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Eggs, meats, cheese, and rotating fillings receive the same careful treatment as the pastry case, making the Third Ward production shop useful well after the morning doughnut run.
St. Paul Fish Company | Historic Third Ward, Milwaukee · Historic Third Ward
St. Paul Fish Company turns its seafood market access into memorable sandwiches inside the Milwaukee Public Market. The lobster roll draws attention, but fried fish, grilled preparations, and other daily options give the counter more range, all served amid the market's energetic communal seating.
Riley's Social House & Sandwich Co. · Historic Third Ward
Riley's combines a neighborhood bar atmosphere with a menu built seriously around sandwiches. Toasted breads, generous fillings, crisp sides, and a well matched beer list make it a comfortable Third Ward stop for an easy dinner, a game, or a late afternoon meal with friends.
Glorioso's Italian Market · Brady Street
Glorioso's uses the depth of its Italian market in a sandwich counter stocked with cured meats, cheeses, peppers, and house sauces. Longstanding combinations such as the spicy Human Torch carry real neighborhood character, and the adjoining aisles make it easy to leave with pantry provisions too.
What’s your #1 Sandwiches in Milwaukee?
Rank your top five and be the first to set Milwaukee's local ranking.