51 E Gay St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA
Hours
- Mon · Today11 AM – 9 PM
- Tue11 AM – 9 PM
- Wed11 AM – 9 PM
- Thu11 AM – 9 PM
- Fri11 AM – 10 PM
- Sat4 PM – 10 PM
- Sun4 PM – 8 PM
How locals rank it
In Columbus
From the local food press
Editor’s picks from published local guides
Columbus Monthly put this East Gay Street pizzeria level with the North Market stall for New York-style slices, separated only by half a point. The magazine calls it an authentic East Coast experience down to the parking difficulties, with the thinnest crust of the five it tried and a crispy brown bottom that offers a pleasing chew. Order a cheese slice at the counter.
Picks from Columbus Monthly
What’s your #1 Pizza in Columbus?
Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.