Skip to content

Get the iOS app→

Hibbard's Custard · Buffalo, NY · Top Tier

TOP TIERRestaurant profile

Get the iOS app→

Front page
Buffalo, NY
Hibbard's Custard

Buffalo, NY·Lewiston·Restaurant

Hibbard's Custard

Verified

105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092, USA★4.6(715)

ice-cream
frozen-custard

The verdict

How Hibbard's Custard ranks

Ice Cream in Buffalo, NY
No consensus yet · open for first picks
Unranked

Plan a visit

Hours & how to get there

Top Tier

Your city, ranked.

A publication of local food consensus. Editorial picks cited from reputable sources; community rankings cast by diners who actually went.

Browse

Front page
All cities
About Top Tier
How the consensus works

Help & legal

Support
Privacy
Terms

Read on your phone

Every ranking on this site is built in the iOS app by locals. Install it to rank your own Top 5.

Get the iOS app→

© 2026 Top Tier. Published with opinions.toptiereats.app

Today · Mon11 AM – 8 PM

Mon11 AM – 8 PM
Tue11 AM – 8 PM
Wed11 AM – 8 PM
Thu11 AM – 8 PM
Fri11 AM – 8 PM
Sat11 AM – 8 PM
Sun11 AM – 8 PM

Directions ↗Website ↗(716) 754-4218

Top Tier on iOS

Where does Hibbard's Custard sit for you?

Rank it in the iOS app. Your take joins the consensus.

Get the iOS app→