Skip to content
New Haven, CT

Island Spice Restaurant

Caribbean, Jamaican

459 Winthrop Ave, New Haven, CT 06511, USA

459 Winthrop Ave, New Haven, CT 06511, USA

Hours
  • Mon6:30 AM – 8 PM
  • Tue6:30 AM – 8 PM
  • Wed6:30 AM – 8 PM
  • Thu · Today6:30 AM – 8 PM
  • Fri6:30 AM – 8 PM
  • SatClosed
  • Sun7 AM – 6 PM

How locals rank it

In New Haven
Caribbean in New HavenNot ranked yet

From the local food press

Editor’s picks from published local guides
  • An off-Whalley Jamaican restaurant that Donna Tracey founded in 2010 after arriving from Jamaica, now carried on by her daughter Nadine. New Haven Independent profiled the Oxtail Lunch as one of its most-ordered takeout plates: oxtail with rice and beans, carrots, and cabbage, described in loving sensory detail. Donna opened the place wanting to bring what she considered real, authentic Jamaican cooking to the city. Order the Oxtail Lunch.

    Picks from New Haven Independent and Yale Daily News

What’s your #1 Caribbean in New Haven?

Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.