40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077, USA
Hours
- MonClosed
- Tue8 AM – 4 PM
- Wed8 AM – 4 PM
- Thu8 AM – 4 PM
- Fri8 AM – 4 PM
- Sat8 AM – 4 PM
- Sun · TodayClosed
How locals rank it
In Indianapolis
From the local food press
Editor’s picks from published local guides
A Zionsville pie shop where owner Kelly Maucere turns out scratch-made classics: Mom's Original, the Dutch apple with tart Granny Smiths that got the business rolling, plus Hoosier sugar cream and pumpkin. The more unusual pies, such as pineapple, red velvet, Confetti Birthday and My Elvis PB & Banana Cream, have their own followings among more than 40 recipes, with Pumpkin Praline in fall and Thin Mint Madness in Girl Scout cookie season. Slices also turn up on dessert menus at northside restaurants. Order Mom's Original and a slice of sugar cream.
Picks from Indianapolis Monthly
What’s your #1 Pie Shops in Indianapolis?
Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.