29 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, USA
- Mon4 PM – 1 AM
- Tue4 PM – 1 AM
- Wed4 PM – 1 AM
- Thu · Today4 PM – 1 AM
- Fri1 PM – 1 AM
- Sat4 PM – 1 AM
- Sun1 PM – 1 AM
How locals rank it
From the local food press
- Cheap Eats
Old Town Tavern keeps a genuine neighborhood-bar pulse in the middle of polished downtown Carmel. The narrow room, inexpensive drinks, burgers, and familiar faces provide a welcome counterweight to the development outside. It is a place for conversation at the bar, a game on television, and an evening with no designed agenda.
Picks from Indianapolis Monthly and Mirror Indy
- Dive Bars
Old Town Tavern keeps a genuine neighborhood-bar pulse in the middle of polished downtown Carmel. The narrow room, inexpensive drinks, burgers, and familiar faces provide a welcome counterweight to the development outside. It is a place for conversation at the bar, a game on television, and an evening with no designed agenda.
Picks from Indianapolis Monthly
What’s your #1 Cheap Eats in Indianapolis?
Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.