Indianapolis, IN
Red Key Tavern
Dive Bar, Burgers, American
5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, USA
5170 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, USA
Hours
- Mon5 PM – Midnight
- Tue5 PM – Midnight
- Wed11 AM – Midnight
- Thu11 AM – Midnight
- Fri · Today11 AM – Midnight
- Sat11 AM – Midnight
- SunClosed
How locals rank it
In Indianapolis
From the local food press
Editor’s picks from published local guides
Red Key Tavern runs on house rules, model airplanes, and an atmosphere preserved through generations. Drinks are straightforward, the burger is a natural companion, and the room rewards guests willing to follow its unhurried rhythm. The College Avenue institution feels cared for rather than curated, with every worn detail carrying part of the story.
Picks from Indianapolis Monthly
Make your own Top 5
Rank your favorites, follow people whose taste you trust, and Love Top 5s you want to keep.
Rank your Top 5