Skip to content
Madison, WI

Toby's Supper Club

Fish Fry, Supper Club

3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718, USA

3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718, USA

Hours
  • Mon3 PM – 9 PM
  • Tue3 PM – 9 PM
  • Wed3 PM – 9 PM
  • Thu3 PM – 9 PM
  • Fri · Today3 PM – 10 PM
  • Sat3 PM – 10 PM
  • SunClosed

From the local food press

Editor’s picks from published local guides
  • Steakhouse

    A family run supper club of more than 55 years, serving steaks alongside a deep Friday fish fry menu that covers baby pike, catfish, cod, and lake perch. It took bronze in the 2025 readers' poll for supper club. The cheese hash browns are a local favorite side dish on their own.

    Picks from Madison Magazine

  • Fish Fry

    Isthmus pick. Classic tavern/supper-club Friday fry with baby pike, catfish, cod or lake perch and the locally-famous cheese hash browns.

    Picks from Madison Magazine and Isthmus

What’s your #1 Fish Fry in Madison?

Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.