OpenFreeMap © OpenMapTiles Data from OpenStreetMap
3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718, USA
- Mon3 PM – 9 PM
- Tue3 PM – 9 PM
- Wed3 PM – 9 PM
- Thu3 PM – 9 PM
- Fri3 PM – 10 PM
- Sat3 PM – 10 PM
- Sun · TodayClosed
From the local food press
- Steakhouse
Toby’s sits near McFarland on South Dutch Mill Road and is one of the supper clubs Mary Bergin collected in her Wisconsin Supper Club Cookbook, as the Cap Times reports. Its reviewer calls it a personal favorite for both the food and the ambience, singling out the fried perch and the hashbrowns with American cheese on top. Friday brings a fish fry crowd dense enough that the paper marvels at how servers still find first-timers in it.
Picks from The Cap Times, Madison Magazine, and Wisconsin State Journal
- Fish Fry
Isthmus pick. Classic tavern/supper-club Friday fry with baby pike, catfish, cod or lake perch and the locally-famous cheese hash browns.
Picks from Madison Magazine and Isthmus
What’s your #1 Fish Fry in Madison?
Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.