Nobody’s claimed this yet
Be the first local to put Burgers in Tampa Bay on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.
Start a Top 5 for BurgersEditor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Tampa Magazine. Updated August 2026.
Boulon Brasserie and Bakery · Water Street
Boulon puts a polished brasserie frame around its burger, balancing a rich patty with careful toppings and a well-made bun. Order it alongside something sharper or lighter from the menu, since the contrast keeps the meal from feeling like an isolated luxury sandwich.
El Cap Restaurant · St. Petersburg
El Cap is a St. Petersburg burger counter with decades of neighborhood history, a compact menu, and little interest in unnecessary ornament. Order a straightforward cheeseburger before adding extras, since the appeal lies in the griddled patty, soft bun, and familiar proportions rather than elaborate toppings.
Mighty Fine · Tampa Bay
Mighty Fine treats the burger as a tightly assembled diner plate, with a crisp-edged patty, melted cheese, and restrained toppings. Keep the first order simple enough to judge the griddle work, then add fries or another side. Its compact Cass Street room favors a focused counter meal.
Engine No. 9 · South Tampa
Engine No. 9 builds large, highly composed burgers in a lively Downtown St. Petersburg bar, with toppings that can move from familiar to deliberately excessive. Choose one combination with a clear central idea rather than the longest ingredient list, and split an order if the table wants to compare styles.
Thee Burger Spot · Seminole Heights
Thee Burger Spot is a compact Tampa Street counter built around griddled burgers, generous portions, and direct neighborhood service. A classic cheeseburger gives the clearest introduction, while one house combination can show the kitchen's more playful side. Expect a practical stop rather than a long dining-room experience.