Skip to content

Birmingham, AL

For Italian in Birmingham, the local food press points to Bottega, Gianmarco's Restaurant, and Bettola. Picks from Bham Now and The Birmingham Times, updated July 2026.

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Bham Now and The Birmingham Times. Updated July 2026.

Bottega · Highland Park
Bottega expresses Frank Stitt's affection for Italy through handmade pasta, roasted meats, seafood, vegetables, and a dining room built for gracious hospitality. The food respects regional tradition without treating it as a museum piece. Its Highland Avenue home gives dinner architectural drama balanced by warmth from the kitchen and staff.
Gianmarco's Restaurant · Homewood
Gianmarco's feels like a family Italian dining room that has grown naturally into a Birmingham institution. Pasta, veal, seafood, wine, and deeply flavored sauces fill a menu made for lingering, while the separate wine bar offers another way to visit. Homewood regulars give the Broadway Street room its enduring energy.
Bettola · Southside
Bettola brings regional Italian cooking and wood fired pizza together at Pepper Place. Handmade pasta, charred crusts, seasonal vegetables, and carefully sourced ingredients give the compact menu depth without excess. The intimate room keeps diners close to the oven and to the energy of chef James Lewis's kitchen.
Lé Fresca · 2nd Avenue North
Lé Fresca channels the ease of an Italian cafe through fresh pasta, crisp pizza, salads, and a memorable house made sandwich. The downtown room works equally well for lunch or a relaxed dinner, with wine and espresso completing the rhythm. A compact menu allows dough, sauce, cheese, and carefully prepared fillings to receive close attention across different dishes.
Trattoria Zaza · Downtown
Trattoria Zaza shifts easily from morning through lunch with Roman style pizza, pasta, baked goods, and a relaxed cafe sensibility. The counter display invites spontaneous choices, while the narrow downtown room feels connected to the street outside. Its cooking is casual in format but attentive to texture and seasonal ingredients.

What’s your #1 Italian in Birmingham?

Rank your top five and be the first to set Birmingham's local ranking.

More Birmingham rankings

Italian in nearby cities