Skip to content

Chicago, IL

No local rankings yet · editorial below

Tamalerias and counters The Infatuation and Time Out Chicago single out for the masa itself, from a Dunning diner counter to a Pilsen shop that steams every tamal in banana leaf.

Part of Holiday in Chicago

Nobody’s claimed this yet

Be the first local to put Tamales in Chicago on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.

Start a Top 5 for Tamales

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in The Infatuation and Time Out Chicago. Updated September 2026.

Santa Masa Tamaleria · Dunning
The Infatuation rates this Dunning counter above every other tamal in the city, calling the masa smooth, buttery and fluffy enough to make cumulus clouds jealous. You eat it at a long diner-style kitchen counter. Order the pollo en salsa roja, shredded chicken in a spicy guajillo sauce, which the review names as its favourite of the lot, and take the rajas y queso with poblano, caramelized onion and melted cheese alongside. Finish with the tamal de fresa, cake-textured under dulce de leche and powdered sugar.
Yvolina's Tamales · Pilsen
Where most Chicago tamale shops reach for a corn husk, Time Out reports that Yvolina's steams every tamal in a neat cocoon of banana leaves, which leaves the masa shell moister. The fillings run from chicken with salsa verde or rojo through tofu with green tomatillo and quinoa with lentils, and many of them are free of meat and animal products. Order whichever end of that spectrum you prefer and ask for the shop's mole sauce over it, which is how Time Out says to eat them.
El Milagro Tortillas · Pilsen
Time Out describes a sunny Pilsen cafe painted bright purple, yellow and orange inside and out, sitting next door to one of the city's most successful makers of corn and flour tortillas. Employees put those tortillas to work on chicken legs in mole rojo and slow-cooked beef in a rich tomato sauce. Order the tamales, which Time Out calls satisfying and recommends as the portable option, though the room is the part you cannot take with you.