Columbus, OH
No local rankings yet · editorial below
In season through November 30part of Fall in Columbus
Nobody’s claimed this yet
Be the first local to put Pie Shops in Columbus, OH on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.
Start a Top 5 for Pie ShopsEditor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Columbus Monthly and Step Out Columbus. Updated September 2026.
Pattycake Bakery · Clintonville
This vegan bakery in Clintonville bakes a series of Ohio Pride Pies. The Dutch apple pie is made with local Goldrush apples from Ochs Fruit Farm in Lancaster and topped with streusel. Order the Dutch apple.
Dough Mama Clintonville
Classically trained pastry chef Perrie Wilkof baked for places like Skillet and Yellow Brick Pizza before her pies grew beloved enough to need a shop of their own, this Clintonville storefront. The brown butter pumpkin pie is the showpiece: a spiced pumpkin and sweet potato custard in a buttery crust. Order the brown butter pumpkin pie.
Resch's Bakery · Gahanna
This bakery has been in business for more than a century and is known for its donuts, but its pumpkin pie earns a spotlight of its own, rich and warm, a slice of Columbus history to carry home. Order the pumpkin pie.
Little Ladies Soft Serve · Westerville
Soft serve comes in pie form year-round at this Westerville shop. The Aggie, for buckeye lovers, combines peanut butter and vanilla soft serve with puppy chow, buckeyes, peanut butter sauce and hot fudge. The Ruby, for fans of strawberry pretzel salad, brings strawberry and vanilla soft serve, strawberry puree, candied pretzels and graham cracker crumble. Order the Aggie or the Ruby.