City Consensus · New York
Black-and-White Cookies in New York
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Black-and-White Cookies in New York below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 3 Black-and-White Cookies in New York
Editorial canon from New York's most-trusted food publications. Glaser's (closed 2018) is intentionally omitted.
- #1
William Greenberg Desserts
Upper East Side
“Since 1946. With Glaser's gone, the undisputed standard — cakey base, crisp fondant, perfectly even halves.”
- #2
Zabar's
Upper West Side
“The UWS deli-counter version — oversize, soft, and the sentimental favorite of uptown purists.”