The Record · New York, NY · Ice Cream
Ice Cream in New York, NY, ranked by the locals who eat there.
Local consensus · Real turnout · No paid placement
Unclaimed
Nobody’s ranked this yet.
Top Tier editorial has a take on ice cream in New York, NY below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have filed theirs.
Editorial picks
Top 5 Ice Cream in New York
Top Tier EditorialSourcesThe InfatuationResyTime Out New York
- №1
Caffè Panna
Gramercy
“Hallie Meyer's Italian-style gelato daily — whipped cream from imported Italian dairy; the #1 most-cited NYC ice cream of the post-pandemic era.”
- №2
il laboratorio del gelato
Lower East Side
“Jon Snyder's 200+ rotating flavors — the technical gold standard for NYC gelato since 2002; supplies many top restaurants.”
- №3
L'Albero Dei Gelati
Park Slope
“Park Slope's Italian gelato destination — gianduia, stracciatella, and seasonal rotations the Infatuation ranks among NYC's finest.”
- №4
Sugar Hill Creamery
Harlem
“Harlem standard-bearer from Nick and Petrushka Larsen — flavors like Pon De Replay and Orange Blossom Special; Infatuation and Resy consensus pick.”
- №5
Malai
Carroll Gardens
“Pooja Bavishi's South Asian-inflected ice cream — masala chai, rose cardamom, saffron; reshaped the NYC scoop-shop landscape.”
Add to the record
Your ice cream. On the record.
You just read what New York, NY has filed. Add your picks — right here on the web — and see where your taste lands.