City Consensus · New York
Italian in New York
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Italian in New York below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 5 Italian in New York
Editorial canon from New York's most-trusted food publications.
- #1
Rezdôra
Flatiron
“Michelin-starred Emilian pasta from chef Stefano Secchi — Pete Wells' 3-star review reset the pasta conversation.”
- #2
Via Carota
West Village
“Jody Williams and Rita Sodi's all-day trattoria — James Beard Outstanding Restaurant 2023; consensus canon.”
- #3
Lilia
Williamsburg
“Missy Robbins' handmade pastas — the agnolotti and cacio e pepe fritters remain the city's toughest reservation.”
- #4
Misi
Williamsburg
“Missy Robbins' pasta temple — the occhi and vegetable antipasti are staff picks across Eater and NYT.”
- #5
I Sodi
West Village
“Rita Sodi's Tuscan — the lasagna alla buongustaia is a NYC institution per NYT, Eater, and Grub Street.”