New York, NY
For Pizza in New York, the local food press points to L'industrie Pizzeria - Williamsburg, L&B Spumoni Gardens, and Lucali. Picks from The Infatuation, updated April 2026.
Editor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in The Infatuation. Updated April 2026.
L'industrie Pizzeria - Williamsburg
The Infatuation's top-rated slice shop (9.1) — Italian ingredients married to a classic New York-style crust.
L&B Spumoni Gardens · Gravesend
The Infatuation (9.0) on the 1938-era square: signature sauce-on-top slice that achieves textural perfection.
Lucali · Carroll Gardens
The Infatuation (8.9) — thin New York-style pies with crunchy crusts, minced garlic, and a sweet-tangy tomato sauce.
Una Pizza Napoletana · Lower East Side
The Infatuation (8.9) calls this the best Neapolitan pizza in NYC — and possibly the world.
Mama's TOO! Upper West Side
The Infatuation (8.8) — an Upper West Side slice-shop standout on their ranked NYC pizza list.
What’s your #1 Pizza in New York?
Rank your top five and be the first to set New York's local ranking.