503 E Nifong Blvd Ste C, Columbia, MO 65201, USA
Hours
- Mon10 AM – 6 PM
- Tue10 AM – 6 PM
- Wed10 AM – 6 PM
- Thu10 AM – 6 PM
- Fri10 AM – 6 PM
- Sat10 AM – 5 PM
- Sun · TodayClosed
How locals rank it
In Columbia
From the local food press
Editor’s picks from published local guides
Jeanne Plumley and her daughter relaunched this family bakery, which Plumley first ran with Peggy Day, and three generations of women now make its pies from scratch under golden lattice crusts. Flavors run from blue goose, caramel apple and banoffee to strawberry pop tart, many made half or fully sugar-free on request, with seasonal pies like pumpkin chiffon and butterscotch bourbon pecan. This entry is the Nifong Boulevard shop, one of two. Order the blueberry streusel.
Picks from Vox Magazine and Inside Columbia
What’s your #1 Pie Shops in Columbia?
Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.