St. Louis, MO
Failoni's Restaurant is St. Louis’s #1 in St. Louis Style Pizza, from 1 local’s ranking.
Community Ranking
Built from 1 local’s ranking · consensus is forming · updated 6 months ago
Would your top five be different?
Rank your St. Louis Style PizzaTop 5s
1 listMattFounder@biznut1.Failoni's Restaurant2.Nick & Elena's Pizzeria3.BJ's Bar and Restaurant4.Affton Pizza Company5.Uncle Leo's PizzaMatt's Top 5
Editor’s picks
Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Sauce Magazine, St. Louis Magazine, and Feast Magazine. Updated September 2026.
Imo's Pizza
Ed and Margie Imo opened their first pizzeria at Thurman and Shaw in 1964. Their thin-crust, square-cut pies with Provel spread to nearly 100 stores. Provel blends Swiss, provolone and cheddar for a creamy, smoky tang. The Hampton Avenue location near Forest Park is the one listed here; order a pie to taste that cheese blend.
Farotto's · Rock Hill
Betty and Lou Farotto opened this Rock Hill pizzeria in 1956 with three tables and carhop service. Additions grew it to roughly 6,000 square feet; the pizza pickup area was the original space. Their nephew Jeff Parrott now runs it on the same recipes. St. Louis-style pizza shares the menu with fish, chicken, pasta and a meatball sandwich.
Monte Bello Pizzeria · Lemay
The Petrillo family opened Monte Bello in 1950. Owner Tom Nix found the handwritten original recipes and returned to a thin crust, barely sweet tomato sauce and a Provel-free cheese blend. In the basement room, square pies arrive on metal sheet pans amid checked tablecloths and faded murals. Try Tom's Special or the house Italian sausage.
Pizza-A-Go-Go · Lindenwood Park
Frank LaFata opened Pizza-A-Go-Go on Grand Avenue in 1967. His son Paul now runs it on Scanlan Avenue in Lindenwood Park, keeping the recipes. The hand-tossed dough is moderately thick with straightforward toppings. Order a pie and a soda.
Pirrone's Pizzeria · Florissant
Jay Jaworski and Rick Puckett began working at Pirrone's in 1980 as teenagers and bought it at 21. The dough, sauce, sausage, meatball and hamburger recipes go back to its first St. Louis-style pie in 1976. Jerry's Special has an oiled ultra-thin crust, slightly sweet Sicilian-style sauce with crushed red pepper, pepperoni and crisp bacon under the local cheese blend.
What’s your #1 St. Louis Style Pizza in St. Louis?
Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.