Skip to content

Tampa Bay, FL

For Italian in Tampa Bay, the local food press points to Beccofino Italian Bistro, Esposito's Italian Restaurant And Bar, and Osteria Natalina. Picks from Tampa Magazine, updated July 2026.

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Tampa Magazine. Updated July 2026.

Beccofino Italian Bistro · South Tampa
Beccofino is a South MacDill bistro focused on handmade pasta, restrained sauces, and a compact regional Italian menu. Begin with a pasta that keeps the noodle visible rather than the heaviest sauce, then add a vegetable or seafood preparation. The intimate room rewards a focused order.
Esposito's Italian Restaurant And Bar · Carrollwood
Esposito's serves classic Italian-American cooking in Carrollwood through pasta, cutlets, seafood, and generous shared dishes. Bring enough people to compare a red-sauce staple with something less familiar, and use a starter to pace the table. The restaurant's scale makes more sense for a gathering than a rushed solo meal.
Osteria Natalina · Palma Ceia
Osteria Natalina is an intimate South MacDill room with handmade pasta, regional specials, and a close connection between the dining room and kitchen. Ask about the day's pasta before settling on a familiar favorite, then choose a starter that reflects the same region or season without repeating the sauce.
Rocca · Tampa Heights
Rocca approaches Italian cooking with precise technique, handmade pasta, crudo, and tableside flourishes in Tampa Heights. A pasta course is essential, but the kitchen's range becomes clearer when the table also orders something raw or vegetable-led. Leave room for a composed dessert rather than ending after the richest savory plate.
Bella's Italian Cafe · SoHo
Bella's has served South Howard with pasta, pizza, and familiar Italian comfort for decades. Pair one house pasta with a pizza or lighter starter when sharing, since the long menu is easier to understand through contrast. The relaxed dining room fits both neighborhood dinners and larger celebratory tables.

What’s your #1 Italian in Tampa Bay?

Rank your top five and be the first to set Tampa Bay's local ranking.

More Tampa Bay rankings

Italian in nearby cities