Orlando, FL
For Italian in Orlando, the local food press points to IL Pescatore, Prato, and Francesco's Ristorante & Pizzeria. Picks from Orlando Magazine and Orlando Weekly, updated July 2026.
Editor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Orlando Magazine and Orlando Weekly. Updated July 2026.
IL Pescatore · Colonialtown
IL Pescatore is a compact neighborhood red sauce restaurant with a lived in dining room and a broad roster of familiar Italian American plates. Pasta, seafood, chicken, veal, and pizza arrive in generous portions. The appeal rests on consistency and warmth rather than polished presentation or a trend driven menu.
Prato · Winter Park / Park Avenue
Prato brings a modern Italian sensibility to a busy Park Avenue room. Wood fired pizza, house pasta, vegetables, and shareable plates are built around direct flavors and seasonal ingredients. The open kitchen and energetic dining room make it useful for groups, while the cooking remains disciplined enough for a focused meal.
Francesco's Ristorante & Pizzeria · Maitland
Francesco's is a Maitland dining room grounded in chef Francesco Aiello's Sicilian background. The kitchen covers wood fired pizza, pasta, seafood, and regional specials, with a visible oven and a comfortably traditional atmosphere. It works equally well for a family dinner or a slower meal built around several courses.
ANTONIO'S Maitland
Antonio's combines an upstairs Italian restaurant with a market and cafe downstairs. The dining room takes a classic approach to pasta, veal, seafood, risotto, and wine service, while the market adds imported goods and prepared foods. Its layered format has made the Maitland address useful for both everyday shopping and occasion meals.
Nonno's Italian Restaurant · Altamonte Springs
Nonno's is a family run Sicilian restaurant in Altamonte Springs with a deeply personal menu. Baked pasta, seafood, cutlets, red sauce dishes, and daily specials arrive in a warm, compact room. The cooking feels rooted in household tradition, with generous portions and direct hospitality carrying as much weight as presentation.
What’s your #1 Italian in Orlando?
Rank your top five and be the first to set Orlando's local ranking.