City Consensus · Orlando
Italian in Orlando
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Italian in Orlando below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 4 Italian Restaurants in Orlando
Orlando's Italian picks — cross-referenced from Orlando Magazine's 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice Best Italian podium.
- #1
Prato
Winter Park / Park Avenue
“MICHELIN-recommended Park Avenue favorite — Orlando Weekly's 2024 Best of Orlando voted Prato its top Date Restaurant and #3 Gourmet Pizza.”
- #2
Fresco Cucina Italiana – Dr. Phillips
Dr. Phillips
“Orlando Magazine's 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice #1 Italian — Dr. Phillips' long-running classic Italian kitchen.”
- #3
Armando's - Winter Park
Hannibal Square / Winter Park
“Orlando Magazine's 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice #2 Italian — Hannibal Square neighborhood trattoria with wood-fired pizzas.”
- #4
Enzo's Hideaway Tunnel Bar
Disney Springs / Lake Buena Vista
“Orlando Magazine's 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice #3 Italian — Roman-style pasta in a Prohibition-themed tunnel bar at Disney Springs.”