Columbia, MO
Pizza Tree is Columbia’s #1 in Pizza, from 2 locals’ rankings.
In season through February 15part of Game Day in Columbia
City Consensus
What Columbia, MO locals agree on · updated 6 months ago
Would your top five be different?
Rank your PizzaTop 5s
2 listsMattFounder@biznut1.G & D Pizzaria2.Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown3.The Italian Village4.Pizza Tree5.Flat Branch Pub & BrewingMatt's Top 5
Gabriel DeanRising@gsdd741.Pizza Tree2.Gumby's Pizza3.The Italian Village4.Tony's Pizza Palace5.Shakespeare's Pizza - DowntownGabriel Dean's Top 5
Editor’s picks
Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Vox Magazine. Updated September 2026.
Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
The Mizzou-adjacent institution since 1973. Inside Columbia's 2025 Gold and the default CoMo slice for half a century.
G & D Pizzaria · West Broadway
Greek-family-run thin-crust pizzeria. Inside Columbia's 2025 Silver and a longstanding cross-campus pick.
Pizza Tree · Downtown
Pizza Tree works out of Mojo’s and turns out inventive pies and large rectangular pizzas, with past specials carrying poached eggs, jalapeño poppers and Milanesa pork tenderloin. Owner Johnny G. tells Vox Magazine he went on a pizza odyssey, eating at 32 pizzerias in 31 days, and the rotating selections keep regulars trying slices away from the norm. Grab a slice before a show on Mojo’s stage, and expect the specials board to have moved on by the next visit.
What’s your #1 Pizza in Columbia, MO?
Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.