City Consensus
What Columbia, MO locals agree on · updated 3 months ago
Would your top five be different?
Rank your Pizza →Top 5s
2 listsMattFounder@biznut1.G & D Pizzaria2.Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown3.The Italian Village4.Pizza Tree5.Flat Branch Pub & BrewingMatt's Top 5
Gabriel DeanRising@gsdd741.Pizza Tree2.Gumby's Pizza3.The Italian Village4.Tony's Pizza Palace5.Shakespeare's Pizza - DowntownGabriel Dean's Top 5
Editor’s picks
Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Inside Columbia. Updated June 2026.
Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
The Mizzou-adjacent institution since 1973. Inside Columbia's 2025 Gold and the default CoMo slice for half a century.
G & D Pizzaria · West Broadway
Greek-family-run thin-crust pizzeria. Inside Columbia's 2025 Silver and a longstanding cross-campus pick.
Pizza Tree · Downtown
Downtown by-the-slice shop with rotating specialty pies. Inside Columbia's 2025 Bronze.
What’s your #1 Pizza in Columbia, MO?
Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.