The Record · Columbia, MO · Pizza
Pizza in Columbia, MO, ranked by the locals who eat there.
Local consensus · Real turnout · No paid placement
The local consensus
An early read: Columbia's top pizza is Pizza Tree, filed so far by 2 locals, as of June 2026.
- №2G & D Pizzariapizza · West Broadway
- №3Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtownpizza · Downtown
- №4The Italian Village
- №5Gumby's Pizza
Filed by
2
Columbia locals · Pizza
Kept by the people who live there.
Updated 5 hours ago
How the record is keptAlso on the record
Top 5s from the community
Locals on the record(722)
Individual curators’ Top 5s for pizza in Columbia, MO — the same locals whose picks build the ranking above, but bylined. Newest first.
Editorial picks
Top 3 Pizza in Columbia
Top Tier EditorialSourcesInside Columbia
- №1
Shakespeare's Pizza - Downtown
Downtown
“The Mizzou-adjacent institution since 1973 — Inside Columbia's 2025 Gold and the default CoMo slice for half a century.”
- №2
G & D Pizzaria
West Broadway
“Greek-family-run thin-crust pizzeria — Inside Columbia's 2025 Silver and a longstanding cross-campus pick.”
- №3
Pizza Tree
Downtown
“Downtown by-the-slice shop with rotating specialty pies — Inside Columbia's 2025 Bronze.”
Add to the record
Your pizza. On the record.
You just read what Columbia, MO has filed. Add your picks — right here on the web — and see where your taste lands.