Skip to content

St. Louis, MO

La Pizza is St. Louis’s #1 in Pizza, from 2 locals’ rankings.

In season through February 15part of Game Day in St. Louis

City Consensus
What St. Louis locals agree on · updated 5 months ago
1La Pizza
2Jet's Pizza
6Pizza Head

Would your top five be different?

Rank your Pizza

Top 5s

2 lists
From locals here, newest first
  1. Biff PokarokaEstablished@gary1.La Pizza2.Jet's Pizza3.Racanelli's PizzaBiff Pokaroka's Top 5
  2. MattFounder@biznut1.La Pizza2.Pie Guy Pizza3.Motor Town Pizza4.Dewey's Pizza - U-City5.Pizza HeadMatt's Top 5

Editor’s picks

Sourced from the local food press. As seen in St. Louis Magazine, Feast Magazine, and Sauce Magazine. Updated September 2026.

Pizzeria da Gloria · The Hill
On Marconi Avenue in The Hill, the kitchen uses a dedicated pizza oven. Order the cheeseless pie with thinly sliced roasted eggplant, garlic-chili oil and parsley.
Union Loafers Café and Bread Bakery · Botanical Heights
This bakery makes pizza crust with the delicacy and char of a Neapolitan pie at a New York pie's size and texture. Six varieties run from pepperoni to the Foxglove with cheese and mushrooms. Add the side of marinara, smeared on the crust and topped with soffrito and Grana Padano.
O+O Pizza · Old Webster / Webster Groves
The Olive + Oak team opened this Lockwood Avenue pizzeria in its former restaurant space. Executive chef Mike Risk built crisp, charred thin-crust pizzas around a new oven. Order the O+O Original with tomato sauce, Fior di Latte and pecorino, or build one with Ezzo pepperoni, pistachio pesto and hot honey.
Katie's Pizza & Pasta – Rock Hill
Katie Lee Collier runs this Rock Hill osteria, whose interior carries Ted Collier's paintings. Its Giveback Tuesdays program has raised thousands for charities around the metro. Wood-fired pizzas use ingredients such as Salume Beddu pepperoni salami, pear, figs and prawns.
Pizzeoli Wood Fired Pizza · Soulard
This small Soulard pizzeria opened in 2014 and fires charred, pliable Neapolitan pies in a 900-degree wood oven. A later owner kept the meatless menu and added meat pies, tallow-fried wings, appetizers and desserts. The candlelit room has stained glass and jazz; an online waitlist helps with limited seating. Order a pie and a negroni.

What’s your #1 Pizza in St. Louis?

Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.