Skip to content

Indianapolis, IN

For Bakeries in Indianapolis, the local food press points to Amelia's Fletcher Place, Leviathan Bakehouse, and Circle City Sweets. Picks from Indianapolis Monthly, updated July 2026.

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Indianapolis Monthly. Updated July 2026.

Amelia's Fletcher Place
Amelia's anchors Fletcher Place with naturally leavened loaves, flaky pastry, and a neighborhood counter that keeps useful hours. The Virginia Avenue shop is the original expression of a bakery that now reaches several Indianapolis neighborhoods. Come for crusty bread, stay for a croissant, and leave with something sturdy enough for dinner.
Leviathan Bakehouse · Chatham Arch
Leviathan pairs serious bread and laminated pastry with a full morning menu at its College Avenue cafe. Croissants arrive plain, filled, or built into breakfast sandwiches, while naturally leavened loaves give regulars a reason to return. The room works equally well for a quick pastry run or a slower coffee and breakfast.
Circle City Sweets · 16 Tech
Circle City Sweets brings French technique to a compact counter inside The AMP at 16 Tech. Almond croissants, macarons, muffins, and canele fill a case that can sell down quickly. Cindy Hawkins has spent decades refining the work, and the daily selection rewards an early visit before the most sought-after pastries disappear.
Le Petit Gateau · Carmel
Le Petit Gateau is a Carmel pastry shop shaped by owner Chris Holland's competition background and culinary training. The cases hold filled croissants, scones, specialty cakes, and polished French pastries without losing the feel of a hands-on neighborhood bakery. It is a focused stop for a composed dessert or a box to share.
Mama Ines Mexican Bakery #3 · Northwest Indianapolis
Mama Ines lines long self-service shelves with conchas, danishes, meringues, cinnamon rolls, and fruit-filled pastries. Tongs and a tray are the tools for browsing a colorful selection rooted in Rosa Gaeta's memories of Mexican bread. The Georgetown Road shop offers the full ritual, including the pleasure of finding something still warm.

What’s your #1 Bakeries in Indianapolis?

Rank your top five and be the first to set Indianapolis's local ranking.

More Indianapolis rankings

Bakeries in nearby cities