City Consensus · Orlando
Seafood in Orlando
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Seafood in Orlando below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 4 Seafood Restaurants in Orlando
Orlando's seafood picks — cross-referenced from Orlando Magazine's 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice podium and the Orlando Weekly 2024 Best of Orlando readers' poll.
- #1
Reel Fish Coastal Kitchen and Bar
Winter Park
“Orlando Magazine 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice #1 Seafood AND top-three Best Restaurant overall — chef Fabrizio Schenardi's Winter Park coastal kitchen.”
- #2
The Nauti Lobstah
Apopka
“Orlando Magazine 2024 Readers' Choice #2 Seafood and Orlando Weekly's #2 Best Seafood — New England-style shack with what it bills as Florida's biggest lobster roll.”
- #3
High Tide Harry's
East Orlando
“Orlando Weekly 2024 Best of Orlando #1 Seafood — 30-year-old Semoran Boulevard institution praised as 'still a catch' in the publication's long-form review.”
- #4
Paddlefish
Disney Springs / Lake Buena Vista
“Orlando Magazine 2024 Dining Awards Readers' Choice #3 Seafood — three-story riverboat seafood spot at Disney Springs.”