Skip to content

Pittsburgh, PA

No local rankings yet · editorial below

Nobody’s claimed this yet

Be the first local to put Italian in Pittsburgh on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.

Start a Top 5 for Italian

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Pittsburgh Magazine, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, and Pittsburgh City Paper. Updated August 2026.

DiAnoia's Eatery · Strip District
DiAnoia's Eatery moves from breakfast and lunch into a full evening menu of house pasta, red sauce staples, and Italian American comfort dishes. The Strip District room is casual and busy, with a bakery case and bar supporting the all day format. Pittsburgh Magazine reviewed how the restaurant connects traditional and contemporary approaches.
Dish Osteria Bar · South Side
Dish Osteria Bar is a compact South Side dining room rooted in Sicilian cooking. Handmade pasta, seafood, vegetables, and a focused wine list define the meal, while the late evening atmosphere gives it the character of a neighborhood osteria. Pittsburgh Magazine and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette both include Dish in current citywide restaurant coverage.
Bar Marco · Strip District
Bar Marco serves seasonal Italian cooking inside a former Strip District firehouse. The kitchen favors concise preparations, handmade pasta, and ingredients sourced with care, complemented by a thoughtful wine program. Its intimate dining room and hospitality model have made it a durable part of the neighborhood, reflected in current coverage from both local publications.
Senti Restaurant · Lawrenceville
Senti Restaurant brings Northern Italian cooking to a bright Lawrenceville room lined with contemporary art. Pasta, risotto, seafood, and composed meat dishes anchor the menu, with an Italian wine list that supports the kitchen's restrained style. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette includes Senti in its current restaurant package for the city.
Alla Famiglia · Allentown
Alla Famiglia offers an expansive Italian American dinner in a converted Allentown townhouse. Large portions, tableside touches, pasta courses, and richly sauced chops make the experience deliberately celebratory. Pittsburgh City Paper's current readers coverage names the restaurant in its Italian category, reflecting the loyalty built around its long running format.

More Pittsburgh rankings

Italian in nearby cities