412 Main St, Utica, NY 13501, USA
- Mon7 AM – 3 PM
- Tue7 AM – 3 PM
- Wed7 AM – 3 PM
- Thu7 AM – 3 PM
- Fri7 AM – 3 PM
- Sat7 AM – 3 PM
- Sun · Today7 AM – 3 PM
From the local food press
- Utica Tomato Pie
Rome Sentinel's feature on chef Anthony Amodio's Bagg's Square salumeria centers the tomato pie he built his catering reputation on, which he carried onto the new deli's menu when it opened near Union Station in fall 2025, and the paper's Global Cuisine series named the tomato pie again the following spring. Order it by the slice or as a tray to carry out, alongside a gourmet Italian sandwich on house-baked bread.
Picks from Barking Doodle, Lite 98.7, and Rome Sentinel
- Bakeries
Rome Sentinel's dedicated feature and its Global Cuisine series both cover chef Anthony Amodio's Bagg's Square salumeria, where the baked goods run to bread, cookies, cakes and his signature tomato pie. The tomato pie is the thing to carry out, alongside fresh-baked bread and cookies from an Italian deli that doubles as a neighborhood bakery on Main Street.
Picks from Mohawk Valley Living and Rome Sentinel
What’s your #1 Bakeries in Utica?
Rank your top five and it joins the local ranking.