City Consensus · Utica
Utica Tomato Pie in Utica
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Utica Tomato Pie in Utica below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 4 Utica Tomato Pies
Rectangular focaccia-style dough, tomato sauce, no cheese (or minimal) — the Sicilian-descended sheet pie sold at Utica bakeries and delis. O'Scugnizzo has been doing it since 1914. Per Barking Doodle's tomato pie roundup.
- #1
O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria
Downtown Utica
“Founded 1914 by Eugenio Burlino — ranked the 2nd-oldest pizzeria in America. Originally sold only tomato pie (no mozzarella). The canonical Utica version.”
- #2
Roma Sausage & Deli
East Utica
“Decades-old Italian deli. Secret family-recipe sauce — the right sweet-tart balance, fresh herbs, cold-from-the-case slices.”
- #3
Napoli's Italian Bakery & Deli
West Utica
“Bakery-first approach — thin crispy crust, flavorful sauce, herbs. The go-to for a tomato-pie tray to bring to a party.”
- #4
Holland Farms Bakery & Deli - Yorkville
Yorkville
“Operating since 1955. Flaky, buttery crust with vibrant tomato sauce — the bakery-pie end of the spectrum.”