City Consensus
What Rochester locals agree on · updated 1 month ago
Would your top five be different?
Rank your Dive Bars →Top 5s
1 list- Mike B@fishmaster1.Docksiders Pub & Oven2.The Retreat3.Whiskey's Upper Deck4.Dave's Long Pond Pub5.Braddock Bay Tavern & GrillMike B's Top 5
Editor’s picks
Sourced from the local food press. As seen in CITY Magazine and Democrat and Chronicle (via Yahoo). Updated July 2026.
Lux Lounge · South Wedge
Lux Lounge on South Avenue won Best Dive Bar in CITY Magazine's readers' poll and separately took Best Bar to Drink Solo, a South Wedge fixture built around its house pour, the three-dollar Pabst Smear, a can of PBR with a well shot. Longtime bartender Tony Hayward is part of the draw. Order a Pabst Smear and settle in.
Bug Jar · East End
The Bug Jar on Monroe Avenue has been a Rochester fixture since 1991, doubling as a dive bar and a music venue with a touring-band reputation. The Democrat and Chronicle's dive-bar feature quoted longtime employee Todd Groemminger on what makes a real dive: history, lived-in, a second home. Come for a show and a cheap drink at the bar.
Salinger's · Downtown
Salinger's on East Avenue opened in 1996 and has run under the same ownership group since 2013, a downtown tavern with a New York dive feel. The Democrat and Chronicle named it among Rochester's favorite dive bars. It keeps late hours downtown. Order a beer and a shot and stay a while.
Thirsty's · Pittsford
Thirsty's on State Street in Pittsford has been a local favorite since 1971, a no-pretense village bar the Democrat and Chronicle called what every bar aspires to be. More than fifty years in, it still keeps a welcoming, unfussy room. Order a cold draft and a seat at the bar.
What’s your #1 Dive Bars in Rochester?
Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.