Salt Lake City, UT
For Ice Cream in Salt Lake City, the local food press points to normal ice cream store, Dolcetti Gelato, and Rockwell Ice Cream | Local, Super-Premium. Picks from Salt Lake Magazine, updated July 2026.
Editor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Salt Lake Magazine. Updated July 2026.
normal ice cream store · Central 9th
Normal uses a small batch soft serve base as a canvas for monthly flavors, sauces, crunchy toppings, and playful composed cups. The shop can be experimental, but the texture of the ice cream remains the anchor. Its 900 South storefront makes a convenient final stop after dinner along the Central Ninth corridor.
Dolcetti Gelato · 9th & 9th
Dolcetti makes gelato and sorbet in a richly decorated 9th and 9th shop. Flavors rotate, moving from familiar chocolate and pistachio toward coconut sticky rice, herbs, fruit, and other combinations shaped by the owners' travels. House macarons and espresso make it possible to turn a scoop into a more deliberate dessert.
Rockwell Ice Cream | Local, Super-Premium · Downtown
Rockwell focuses on dense, premium ice cream with generous mix ins and flavors that lean into caramel, cookies, nuts, and chocolate. The Regent Street shop is compact and convenient to downtown theaters and restaurants. Scoops are substantial, so the clearest approach is to choose one of the shop's layered signatures and let it stand alone.
MONKEYWRENCH · Downtown
MONKEYWRENCH makes its entire frozen dessert menu without dairy, using plant based bases for scoops, shakes, cones, and rotating specials. The flavors aim for the richness and texture of a conventional ice cream shop rather than treating vegan preparation as a compromise. Gallivan Plaza provides an easy downtown setting for a walk up dessert.
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. · Bountiful
Blacksmith makes small batch ice cream in Bountiful with a mix of familiar flavors and seasonal combinations. The Main Street shop emphasizes a smooth, rich base, house developed recipes, and a neighborhood pace rather than novelty for its own sake. It adds a worthwhile northern metro stop to a category otherwise concentrated near downtown Salt Lake.
What’s your #1 Ice Cream in Salt Lake City?
Rank your top five and be the first to set Salt Lake City's local ranking.