St. Louis, MO
Clementine's Naughty & Nice Ice Cream is St. Louis’s #1 in Ice Cream, from 2 locals’ rankings.
City Consensus
What St. Louis locals agree on · updated 3 months ago
Top 5s
2 listsSTL DaveRising@stldave1.Ices Plain & Fancy2.Clementine's Naughty & Nice Ice Cream3.SugarwitchSTL Dave's Top 5
Biff PokarokaEstablished@gary1.Clementine's Naughty & Nice Ice Cream2.Crown Candy Kitchen3.Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge4.Ted Drewes Frozen CustardBiff Pokaroka's Top 5
Editor’s picks
Sourced from the local food press. As seen in St. Louis Magazine, Feast Magazine, and Sauce Magazine. Updated September 2026.
Clementine's Naughty & Nice Ice Cream · Lafayette Square
Tamara Keefe's creamery began as a Lafayette Square parlor and grew with flavors such as Italian butter cookie, coffee, maple pecan bourbon and pink champagne sorbet. Order the gooey butter ice cream, then try a boozy scoop.
Ices Plain & Fancy · Shaw
This Shaw shop makes nitro ice cream, flash-freezing the mix for a silky texture. Order a scoop made at the counter, or take home a pint in a flavor such as vanilla or cherry cordial.
Serendipity Homemade Ice Cream · Webster Groves
Beckie Jacobs' Serendipity has run a scoop shop and appeared on restaurant dessert menus around town for two decades. At the Grove location, take home a hand-packed pint from the case, with flavors such as cookie monster or blueberry cheesecake, or a prepacked classic such as gooey butter or gold coast chocolate.
Gelato Di Riso · The Hill
This gelato shop has locations on The Hill and in Kirkwood. Flavors change regularly; look for amaretto or chocolate hazelnut, alongside dairy-free choices such as pineapple and pink grapefruit. Order a cone or take home a pint or quart.
Sugarwitch · Patch
Sophie Mendelson's South City shop makes ice cream sandwiches designed to be easy to bite without cracking a frozen cookie or squeezing out the filling. The Gideon pairs housemade vanilla ice cream with chocolate-covered pretzel chunks, chewy peanut butter chip brownie and a layer of smooth peanut butter. The shop occupies the former Carondelet Bakery space on Virginia Avenue.
What’s your #1 Ice Cream in St. Louis?
Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.