Skip to content

St. Louis, MO

Frank Papa's Ristorante is St. Louis’s #1 in Italian, from 2 locals’ rankings.

City Consensus
What St. Louis locals agree on · updated 2 months ago
2Il Bel Lago
6Farotto's

Would your top five be different?

Rank your Italian

Top 5s

2 lists
From locals here, newest first
  1. Steve@steve1.Frank Papa's Ristorante2.Paul Manno's Restaurant3.Failoni's Restaurant4.Farotto'sSteve's Top 5
  2. MattFounder@biznut1.Il Bel Lago2.Zia's on The HillMatt's Top 5

Editor’s picks

Sourced from the local food press. As seen in St. Louis Magazine, Sauce Magazine, and St. Louis Post-Dispatch. Updated September 2026.

Pastaria · Clayton
Chef Gerard Craft drew on travels in Italy and friendships made over food and wine for this Clayton restaurant's pastas, pizzas and desserts. Order shaved kale salad, canestri cacio e pepe, four-cheese pizza or butternut squash with herbs, balsamic and hot honey. An online waitlist and a deli next door offer other ways to eat here.
Charlie Gitto's On the Hill
This brick-walled room on The Hill has checkered tablecloths, red sauces and wines, and four veal preparations. Order veal and carrot cake, or look for a courtyard table.
Trattoria Marcella · Lindenwood Park
Brothers Steve and Jamie Komorek serve Italian comfort food at this dining room and sidewalk patio. The lobster risotto is available by request even though it is off the dinner menu. The bar also serves a weekday happy hour.
Peppe's Apt 2 · Kirkwood
Chef-owner Peppe Profeta's Kirkwood dining room has crystal-encrusted mirrors, heavy crown molding and fresh flowers on the tables. Order shrimp scampi: fresh shrimp in truffled breadcrumbs, seared and finished with butter, garlic and lemon. Fettuccine alfredo can replace the default sides, with Parmesan added.
Noto Italian Restaurant · St. Peters
This family-run St. Peters restaurant changes its seasonal menu while keeping Neapolitan pizzas. Order a dish with Noto's burrata, whether on pizza, in pasta or as an appetizer. Cocktails include rotating off-menu choices and the Atrani Fizz with Tuscan vodka, limoncello, basil syrup and club soda. Bacaro, the Venetian aperitivo and cicchetti bar, shares the property.

What’s your #1 Italian in St. Louis?

Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.