Syracuse, NY
For Caribbean in Syracuse, the local food press points to Isla Caribbean Cuisine, Mr. Bigg's Restaurant LLC, and Don Juan Cafe Restaurant. Picks from This is CNY (Advance Media NY), updated July 2026.
Editor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in This is CNY (Advance Media NY). Updated July 2026.
Isla Caribbean Cuisine · Downtown
A downtown Caribbean restaurant that opened as 809 Lounge and rebranded to Isla, cooking across Puerto Rican and Dominican traditions per This is CNY's Don Cazentre. Charlie Miller devoted a Syracuse Sandwiches column to its 13-inch Cuban sandwich: pork marinated a full day, sweet ham, Swiss and Dijon on Cuban bread with a pickle-infused cream cheese spread, griddled in butter and served in three stacked sections with yuca fries. Order the mofongo and the Cuban sandwich with yuca fries.
Mr. Bigg's Restaurant LLC · Northside
A Jamaican and Caribbean counter on North Salina Street that This is CNY's Northside neighborhood guide names as the place for an authentic Caribbean meal. Open since 2013, the kitchen builds around slow-cooked oxtails, jerk chicken, curry chicken, curry goat and stew chicken served with rice and sides. Order the oxtails with rice and two sides, the jerk chicken bowl, or the curry goat.
Don Juan Cafe Restaurant · Southwest side / Grand Ave
One of Syracuse's longest-running Puerto Rican kitchens, serving fresh Puerto Rican cuisine since 1997, per This is CNY's Northside neighborhood guide. The menu runs to generous plates of roasted pork, fried chicken and stewed beef with rice and beans, plus mofongo, empanadas and sweet plantains. Order the mofongo with fried pork, the roasted pork with rice and beans, and an empanada.
What’s your #1 Caribbean in Syracuse?
Rank your top five and be the first to set Syracuse's local ranking.