City Consensus · Syracuse
Pizza in Syracuse
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Pizza in Syracuse below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 4 Pizza in Syracuse
Syracuse made the 2024 Best Pizza Cities list alongside NYC and Rochester. Varsity has been doing it since 1926; Apizza Regionale represents the modern Neapolitan end.
- #1
Apizza Regionale
Armory Square
“The Neapolitan-style benchmark in downtown Syracuse. Wood-fired, short menu, natural-leaven dough — the top of most Syracuse pizza lists.”
- #2
Varsity Pizza Syracuse
University Hill
“Syracuse University-adjacent classic since 1926. Nearly a century of slices — the late-night pilgrimage after a game.”
- #3
Toss & Fire (North Syracuse)
North Syracuse
“Wood-fired, rotating topping specials, strong local following. Yelp top-5 Syracuse pizza regular.”
- #4
Napoli Pizzeria
North Salina
“North Salina neighborhood joint — straightforward slice pizza, Yelp top-3. Old Syracuse.”