City Consensus · Utica
Pizza in Utica
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Pizza in Utica below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 4 Pizza in Utica
O'Scugnizzo (1914) is the 2nd-oldest pizzeria in America — their "upside-down" style (sauce on crust, then cheese on top) defines the local pizza lineage. Food & Wine's Best Pizza in Every State gave New York's nod to O'Scugnizzo.
- #1
O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria
Downtown Utica
“Second-oldest pizzeria in America (1914). Food & Wine's Best Pizza in New York pick. The upside-down style — sauce on crust, cheese on top — defines the Utica pizza lineage.”
- #2
Nina's Pizza
Utica
“Yelp top Utica pizza regular. Neighborhood joint doing old-school Utica sheet pie and slice pizza.”
- #3
Mangia Macrina's Wood Fired Pizza
New Hartford
“The wood-fired modernist take in the New Hartford corridor — the new-school Utica pizza answer to O'Scugnizzo's 110-year lineage.”
- #4
Westie's Pizzeria
Westmoreland
“Suburban Westmoreland go-to with a cult following. Classic Utica-style slice.”