Boston, MA
For Lobster Roll in Boston, the local food press points to Neptune Oyster, James Hook & Co, and Belle Isle Seafood. Picks from The Boston Globe and The Infatuation, updated July 2026.
Editor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in The Boston Globe and The Infatuation. Updated July 2026.
Neptune Oyster · North End
The best-known roll in town. a generous Maine lobster roll on toasted brioche, hot with butter or cold with mayo.
James Hook & Co · Waterfront
A fish shack in the middle of Boston's waterfront. The Hook family has been harvesting shellfish here for a century.
Belle Isle Seafood · Winthrop
Urban seaside spot known for an oversized all-tail lobster roll option (cash only).
Row 34 - Seaport | Boston · Fort Point
Chef Jeremy Sewall's Seaport oyster hall. Warm-butter version with sweet, tender meat, plus a cold option named for his grandmother.
Eventide Fenway
The Globe singles out the unconventional preparation. Lobster on a steamed bao with nutty brown butter that lends umami without overwhelming the meat.
What’s your #1 Lobster Roll in Boston?
Rank your top five and be the first to set Boston's local ranking.