City Consensus · Indianapolis
Steakhouse in Indianapolis
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Steakhouse in Indianapolis below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 5 Steakhouse in Indianapolis
With eight steakhouses inside the Mile Square, red meat sits at the top of Indy's food chain — drawn from Indianapolis Monthly's steakhouse guide and its Best Restaurants coverage.
- #1
St. Elmo Steak House
Wholesale District
“Indianapolis Monthly — continuously operating at the same address since 1902; aged Black Angus and the nationally famous horseradish shrimp cocktail make it the city's most storied restaurant.”
- #2
The Fountain Room
Mass Ave
“Indianapolis Monthly 25 Best — drips with the style of a Wisconsin supper club's fancy city cousin; the Bottleworks-era steakhouse on Mass Ave.”
- #3
Bynum's
South Meridian
“Indianapolis Monthly — a no-frills, family-owned room in head-to-toe wood paneling; the 32-ounce prime rib and bone-in ribeye have powered 30 years of loyalty.”
- #4
Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge
Fletcher Place
“Indianapolis Monthly — the youngest of the bunch, with midcentury charm and a modern supper-club menu that takes you back in time.”
- #5
Prime 47- Indy's Steakhouse
Wholesale District
“Indianapolis Monthly — housed in an 1895 building first home to the Indiana Gas Company; dry-aged cuts in a historic downtown room.”