City Consensus · Omaha
Steakhouse in Omaha
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Steakhouse in Omaha below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 5 Steakhouses in Omaha
Steak Town USA — cross-referenced from Sarah Baker Hansen's Flatwater Free Press Steak Tour rankings, her 38 Essential Omaha Restaurants 2024, and Omaha Magazine's Ultimate Steak Tour.
- #1
The Committee Chophouse
Blackstone
“SBH's Steak Town USA #1 at 4.6/5 — the Cottonwood Hotel (née Blackstone) basement chophouse she calls 'straddling the past and future of Nebraska steakhouses.' Delmonico ribeye, loaded baked potato, shrimp cocktail.”
- #2
The Drover
West Omaha
“SBH calls this 'my most beloved Omaha steakhouse' — her 2024 Top 5 Favorites pick and a 38 Essential. Whiskey-marinated steaks, Western-themed room, cinnamon toffee cheesecake.”
- #3
801 Chophouse
Old Market
“Flatwater Steak Tour 3.7/5 — Morgan Ranch Nebraska Sandhills beef, dry-aged 28+ days, bone-in filet, tableside meat cart. Housed in the Paxton hotel.”
- #4
Johnny's Cafe
South Omaha
“SBH 38 Essential — the century-plus stockyards-era institution (est. 1922) she singles out for hand-sliced onion rings and slow-roasted prime rib. Flatwater Steak Tour 3.0/5.”
- #5
Gorat's
Midtown
“Warren Buffett's longtime haunt (est. 1944) — SBH's 2025 update declares 'Gorat's is good again' after new ownership, with the homemade O.G. meat sauce and carrot cake scoring 4/5 steaks. 25-oz Nebraska Porterhouse is the signature.”