Skip to content

Pittsburgh, PA

No local rankings yet · editorial below

Nobody’s claimed this yet

Be the first local to put Ice Cream in Pittsburgh on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.

Start a Top 5 for Ice Cream

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Pittsburgh Magazine. Updated September 2026.

Page's · South Side
Pittsburgh Magazine includes Page's among the city's enduring frozen dessert stops and reports daily service during the season. The East Carson Street stand is built around soft serve, sundaes, and other familiar dairy bar treats. Its long evening hours make it a straightforward stop after a meal on the South Side.
The Black Canary · Blawnox
Pittsburgh Magazine profiles The Black Canary as a Blawnox shop for ice cream and cold desserts. The Freeport Road storefront offers a focused neighborhood alternative to larger local chains, with weekday and Saturday service documented by the publication. Check the shop's current schedule before making a dedicated trip because its weekly hours vary by day.
Gus & YiaYia’s · North Side
Pittsburgh Magazine documents this family run cart in Allegheny Commons, where Christina Avalon continues the warm weather tradition. The draw is hand shaved ice finished with vivid flavored syrups, served from the familiar cart near West Ohio Street. It is a seasonal operation, so confirm the posted daytime schedule before visiting outside summer's core months.
Crispy Cones · Allison Park
At the Allison Park Crispy Cones shop, warm grilled pastry cones hold ice cream, fillings and toppings. Try the traditional cinnamon-sugar cone with vanilla ice cream, Nutella and KitKat, the combination the local owners recommend. This Pennsylvania franchise has a permanent William Flinn Highway storefront, with the pastry cone itself as much a draw as the ice cream inside.
Leona's Ice Cream · Garfield
Leona’s opened its Garfield scoop shop after years of selling ice cream and oversized cookie sandwiches around Pittsburgh. At the Penn Avenue counter, choose from rotating dairy and dairy-free scoops, or take home a pint or ice cream sandwich. The shop also offers floats and chocolate-dipped frozen bars; flavors change, so the case is worth a look.