Nobody’s claimed this yet
Be the first local to put Seafood in Pittsburgh on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.
Start a Top 5 for SeafoodEditor’s picks
Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Pittsburgh Magazine, NEXTpittsburgh, and TABLE Magazine. Updated September 2026.
FET-FISK restaurant + bar · Bloomfield
Pittsburgh Magazine's restaurant coverage identifies FET-FISK through its seafood driven cooking in Bloomfield. Chef Nik Forsberg approaches fish and shellfish through a seasonal menu shaped by preservation and Nordic and Appalachian ideas. The compact restaurant rewards sharing across the table, especially when the changing menu moves between small plates and fuller preparations.
Penn Avenue Fish Co · Strip District
Pittsburgh Magazine names Penn Avenue Fish Company in its seafood coverage. The Strip District business combines a fish market with a restaurant, keeping the focus on the day's seafood rather than a broad general menu. That dual identity supports both a seated lunch and a stop for fish to prepare at home, with posted restaurant hours guiding visits.
Off The Hook · Warrendale
Off The Hook serves a broad fish and seafood menu in Warrendale. Choose a fish with a scratch-made sauce or one of the prepared entrees; the kitchen also offers steaks and other meat dishes.
Monterey Bay Fish Grotto · Mount Washington
Pittsburgh City Paper names Monterey Bay Fish Grotto in its current seafood category. The Grandview Avenue restaurant pairs a broad fish and shellfish menu with a Mount Washington view, creating a more formal occasion driven option. Reservations and a little extra time are sensible here because the setting is part of the meal's appeal.
Original Oyster House · Downtown
The Original Oyster House serves seafood from a Market Square room with a long local history. Breaded oysters and jumbo fish sandwiches are mainstays, with clam strips and crab cakes offering other ways into the menu. The kitchen sends plates down from the upper floor by dumbwaiter, and the dining room's photographs recall generations of visitors who have stopped in for a meal.