City Consensus · Santa Fe
Italian in Santa Fe
Community consensus
The consensus is still forming.
Top Tier Editorial has a take on Italian in Santa Fe below. The community ranking opens up once a few locals have weighed in.
Top 2 Italian in Santa Fe
Santa Fe's short but deep Italian bench — cross-referenced from Santa Fe Reporter's Best of Santa Fe 2025 Food & Drink winners and the Santa Fe New Mexican's Pasatiempo coverage.
- #1
Piccolino
Agua Fria
“Santa Fe Reporter's Best Italian year after year — Olga Tarango-Jimenez's homestyle Italian-American room with daily-made marinara, house ravioli, and a cannelloni the Pasatiempo review calls the most comforting plate in town.”
- #2
Andiamo!
Railyard
“A perennial Best of Santa Fe Italian winner that turned 30 in 2025 — intimate mission-style bungalow in the Railyard with a Northern-Italian menu that weaves local growers' produce into seasonal Italian classics.”