Skip to content

St. Louis, MO

801 Fish is St. Louis’s #1 in Seafood, from 1 local’s ranking.

Community Ranking
Built from 1 local’s ranking · consensus is forming · updated 5 months ago
1801 Fish

Would your top five be different?

Rank your Seafood

Top 5s

1 list
From locals here, newest first
  1. MackenzieRising@mackenzie1.801 Fish2.Peacemaker Lobster & Crab3.Bristol Seafood Grill4.Broadway Oyster BarMackenzie's Top 5

Editor’s picks

Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Sauce Magazine and St. Louis Magazine. Updated September 2026.

Peacemaker Lobster & Crab · Benton Park
James Beard Award-winning chef-owner Kevin Nashan cooked in New York and New Orleans before building a menu that spans New England, the mid-Atlantic and Louisiana. Shellfish flies in daily, and Companion Baking makes the French-style buns to specification. Order oysters, then a Maine- or Connecticut-style lobster roll, or share a shrimp or lobster boil.
Broadway Oyster Bar · Downtown
This longtime South Broadway room serves oysters with live music and Cajun cocktails. Blue Point and Rappahannock oysters come on the half shell with horseradish and house-made spicy gin cocktail sauce. Other versions include char-grilled oysters with garlic butter and Parmesan, Bienville and Rockefeller. The Oyster Medley brings three preparations together.
Bristol Seafood Grill · Creve Coeur
This Olive Boulevard dining room in Creve Coeur serves fresh fish, sides and lobster bisque. Its happy hour has offered two mini New England lobster rolls. There is a second Bristol in O'Fallon, Missouri.
Extra Wavy · Downtown West
Travis Howard and Tim Wiggins, also of Yellowbelly and Lazy Tiger, built an East Coast fish house on the ground floor of the 160-year-old Centennial Malt House. Order the lobster donut roll or lump crab creste di gallo pasta and explore the raw bar. Some tables are held for walk-ins.
Yellowbelly · Central West End
This Lindell Boulevard room combines tropical drinks with Pacific seafood in a tiki-influenced fish house. Order cheddar biscuits, then a seafood dish with a drink from the bar. Yellowbelly preceded sibling restaurants Extra Wavy and Lazy Tiger.

What’s your #1 Seafood in St. Louis?

Rank your top five and see where your taste lands next to the locals.