Skip to content

Seattle, WA

No local rankings yet · editorial below

In season through November 30part of Fall in Seattle

Nobody’s claimed this yet

Be the first local to put Pie Shops in Seattle on the map. Your Top 5 anchors the City Consensus for everyone who comes next.

Start a Top 5 for Pie Shops

Editor’s picks

Press picks, until locals rank their own Top 5s. Sourced from the local food press. As seen in Seattle Met, The Infatuation, Eater Seattle, and The Seattle Times. Updated September 2026.

Simply Soulful · Central District
A soul food restaurant run by mother and daughter Barbara Collins and Lillian Rambus that grew out of sweet potato pie: the pair started selling Collins's pies at the Kent farmers market in 2011 and sold out every Saturday, opened in Madison Valley three years later and moved into the Jackson Apartments in the Central District in 2022. Sweet potato pies and tarts are made all year, and the dessert case holds them beside banana pudding and bread pudding, with fried chicken, waffles, greens and catfish on the menu. Order a slice of sweet potato pie.
Buddha Bruddah Seattle · Beacon Hill
A Hawaiian-style mixed plate barbecue restaurant on Rainier Avenue South with a loaded bake case up front, worth saving room for even after a big kalua pork plate. The pie to get is the buttery, coconut-rich chocolate haupia pie, and more classic banana, coconut and chocolate cream pies sit beside it. Order a kalua pork plate, then a slice of chocolate haupia pie.
The British Pantry · Redmond
A Redmond shop and restaurant that has become an Eastside stop for British fare and European imports. A savory steak and mushroom pie sits among hearty English classics like bangers and mash, and the dessert menu runs to personal fruit pies in flavors like apple, apple-blueberry, strawberry and rhubarb, served with sweet English cream or even cheese in place of ice cream. Order the steak and mushroom pie, then a personal apple pie.
Dahlia Bakery · Belltown
Tom Douglas's downtown bakery is home to his famous Triple Coconut Cream Pie, with coconut in its crust and toasted coconut on top, sold as a whole pie, a six-inch pie, a slice or a single bite. The small counter also turns out a big pastry selection and breakfast sandwiches on house-made English muffins, with only a few seats outside, so most orders go to go. Order a slice of the Triple Coconut Cream Pie, or a couple of pie bites.
Baked From The Hart · Mount Baker
Bill Hart's Mount Baker pie shop, open since 2016, grew out of a bean pie he first baked as a teenager. Chess pies come in coconut, key lime, lemon and tropical, beside the Sweet Bean Supreme, sweet potato, pumpkin and pecan pies, each in tart, medium and regular sizes. Order a lemon chess pie, then a Sweet Bean Supreme tart.