Italian, everywhere.
The reigning italian pick in 1 city, ranked by the locals who eat there.
Biggest turnout in the country · St. Louis, MO
#1Frank Papa's RistoranteTop Italian in St. Louis, MO · ranked by 2 locals →Not yet ranked
Where locals haven’t ranked italian yet, the local food press points the way. Be the first to publish a Top 5 and the lead is yours.
The Northeast
- Boston
- Buffalo
The Mulberry | Italian Ristorante and Lombardo, per Buffalo Spree
- New Haven
Consiglio's Restaurant and Gioia Cafe and Bar, per CTbites
- New York
Via Carota and Lilia, per The Infatuation
- Philadelphia
Emilia and Dante & Luigi's, per The Infatuation
- Pittsburgh
DiAnoia's Eatery and Dish Osteria Bar, per Pittsburgh Magazine
- Portland, ME
Solo Italiano and ViA VECCHiA, per Portland Old Port
- Providence
Al Forno Restaurant and Camille's, per Rhode Island Monthly
- Rochester
Pane Vino On The River and Rocky's, per CITY Magazine
- Syracuse
Pastabilities and Francesca's Cucina, per Table Hopping
- Utica
Tailor & the Cook and Ventura's, per Stacker
The Midwest
- Chicago
Monteverde Restaurant & Pastificio and Tre Dita, per The Infatuation
- Cincinnati
- Cleveland
Lago East Bank and Casa La Luna, per Cleveland Magazine
- Columbia, MO
The Pasta Factory and Endwell Taverna, per Vox Magazine
- Columbus, OH
Metsi's and Novella Osteria, per The Infatuation
- Detroit
SheWolf Pastificio & Bar and Oak & Reel, per Eater Detroit
- Indianapolis
Vicino and Iaria's Italian Restaurant, per Indianapolis Monthly
- Kansas City
Garozzo's Ristorante Downtown and Lidia’s, per Kansas City Magazine
- Madison
Lombardino's Restaurant and Bar Corallini, per Madison Magazine
- Milwaukee
Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993 and Lupi & Iris, per Milwaukee Magazine
- Minneapolis–St. Paul
Bar La Grassa and Broders' Pasta Bar, per Minnesota Star Tribune
- Omaha
Avoli Osteria and DANTE, per Sarah Baker Hansen (OWH food critic)
- Quincy
- Springfield, MO
Avanzare Italian Dini and Nicola's Ristorante Restaurant, per 417 Magazine
The South
- Asheville
Luminosa and Soprana Rooftop Cucina, per Mountain Xpress
- Atlanta
Gigi's Italian Kitchen & Restaurant and BoccaLupo, per The Infatuation
- Austin
Intero Restaurant and Red Ash, per The Infatuation Austin
- Baltimore
- Birmingham
Bottega and Gianmarco's Restaurant, per Bham Now
- Charleston, SC
- Charlotte
Stagioni - Four Seasons of Food and Mama Ricotta's, per Charlotte Magazine
- Dallas–Fort Worth
Lucia and Via Triozzi, per Dallas Observer
- Hampton Roads
Luce and Sorellas: An Italian Eatery, per Coastal Virginia Magazine
- Houston
Da Marco and Coppa Osteria, per The Infatuation
- Louisville
Volare Italian Ristorante and Pizza Lupo, per LEO Weekly
- Memphis
Pete and Sam's and Andrew Michael, per Memphis Magazine
- Miami / South Florida
Macchialina and Boia De, per The Infatuation
- Nashville
- New Orleans
Mosca's Restaurant | Italian and Pascal's Manale by Dickie Brennan & Co., per Where Y'at
- Oklahoma City
Elisabetta | Fine Italian & Wine and Mary Eddy's Italian Grill, per 405 Magazine
- Orlando
IL Pescatore and Prato, per Orlando Magazine
- Raleigh–Durham
Gocciolina and Mothers & Sons Trattoria, per The News & Observer
- Richmond
Edo's Squid and Dinamo, per Richmond Magazine
- San Antonio
Paesanos Riverwalk and Tre Trattoria, per San Antonio Current
- Savannah
Garibaldi Savannah and Pacci Italian Kitchen + Bar, per Savannah Magazine
- Tampa Bay
Beccofino Italian Bistro and Esposito's Italian Restaurant And Bar, per Tampa Magazine
- Washington, DC
Lupo Verde and Al Tiramisu, per The Infatuation
The West
- Albuquerque
M'tucci's Italian and Trombino's Bistro Italiano, per Gil's Thrilling (And Filling) Blog
- Denver
Tavernetta and Barolo Grill, per Westword
- Honolulu
- Las Vegas
Esther's Kitchen and Mother Wolf Las Vegas, per The Infatuation
- Los Angeles
Bestia and Osteria Mozza, per The Infatuation
- Phoenix
Tratto and Andreoli Italian Grocer, per Phoenix New Times
- Portland, OR
- Sacramento
The Waterboy and Allora, per Sactown Magazine
- Salt Lake City
Matteo Ristorante Italiano and Valter's Osteria, per Salt Lake Magazine
- San Diego
- Santa Fe
- Seattle
Spinasse and Cafe Juanita, per The Infatuation
- SF Bay Area
Cotogna and Penny Roma, per The Infatuation
- Tucson
Locale Neighborhood Italian Restaurant and Vivace Restaurant, per Tucson Foodie