Pie Shops, everywhere.
The reigning pie shops pick in every Top Tier Eats city, ranked by the locals who eat there.
Pie Shops is unclaimed.
No city has published a ranking yet. The first local to publish a Top 5 claims the lead.
The Northeast
- Boston
Petsi Pies and Deluxe Town Diner, per Time Out Boston
- Buffalo
Creekview Restaurant and Zider Zee, per Step Out Buffalo
- New Haven
- New York
- Philadelphia
Denise's Delicacies and Ponzio's Diner-Bakery-Bar, per The Philadelphia Inquirer
- Pittsburgh
Sidecar Coffee and Bake Shop and Piebird Pastry Kitchen, per Pittsburgh Magazine
- Portland, ME
- Providence
PVD Pies and Babes Pie Co., per Rhode Island Monthly
- Rochester
- Syracuse
- Utica
North Star Orchards and Juliano Farms, per Mohawk Valley Living
The Midwest
- Chicago
Hoosier Mama Pie Company and Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits, per Time Out Chicago
- Cincinnati
Bluebird Bakery and Hyde's Restaurant, per Cincinnati Magazine
- Cleveland
Rood and Gray House Pies Westlake, per Cleveland Magazine
- Columbia, MO
Peggy Jean's Pies and Broadway Diner, per Vox Magazine
- Columbus, OH
Pattycake Bakery and Dough Mama Clintonville, per Columbus Monthly
- Detroit
Sister Pie and Sweet Potato Sensations, per Eater Detroit
- Indianapolis
Pots & Pans Pie Co. and Bread Basket Cafe and Bakery, per Indianapolis Monthly
- Kansas City
Rye Leawood and The Upper Crust, per Kansas City Magazine
- Madison
Hubbard Avenue Diner and Norske Nook - DeForest, per Madison Magazine
- Milwaukee
Honeypie Cafe and Blue's Egg + Bakery, per Milwaukee Magazine
- Minneapolis–St. Paul
- Omaha
Carter & Rye and Big Mama's Kitchen and Catering, per Omaha Magazine
- Quincy
- Springfield, MO
Prairie Pie and Dublin's Pass Irish Pub, per 417 Magazine
- St. Louis
Sugaree Baking Company and Damn Fine Hand Pies, per Sauce Magazine
The South
- Asheville
- Atlanta
The Colonnade and The Busy Bee, per The Infatuation
- Austin
Tiny Pies® - Burnet Rd. and Quack's 43rd Street Bakery, per The Infatuation
- Baltimore
Weber's Cider Mill Farm and Fenwick Bakery, per Baltimore Magazine
- Birmingham
JaWanda's Sweet Potato Pies Bakery and Niki's West, per AL.com
- Charleston, SC
Swig & Swine and The Glass Onion, per Charleston City Paper
- Charlotte
Villani's Bakery and Carolina Pie Company, per The Charlotte Observer
- Dallas–Fort Worth
Emporium Pies and Humble: Simply Good Pies, per The Dallas Morning News
- Hampton Roads
Coach House Bar & Grill and Mary's Kitchen, per The Virginian-Pilot
- Houston
House of Pies and Flying Saucer Pie Company, per Houstonia Magazine
- Louisville
Georgia's Sweet Potato Pie Company & Dessert Lounge and The Pie Kitchen, per LEO Weekly
- Memphis
Paulette's Restaurant and A&R Bar-B-Que, per Memphis Magazine
- Miami / South Florida
Joe's Stone Crab and Gramps Getaway, per The Infatuation
- Nashville
- New Orleans
- Oklahoma City
Pie Junkie and Railyard Pie Company, per 405 Magazine
- Orlando
Sister Honey's and Se7enBites, per Orlando Magazine
- Raleigh–Durham
Angus Barn and Bean Traders, per Our State
- Richmond
Proper Pie Co. and Pies and Cakes, per Richmond Magazine
- San Antonio
Tip Top Cafe and The Bread Box, per MySA
- Savannah
The Little Crown by Pie Society and Shabazz Seafood Restaurant, per Savannah Morning News
- Tampa Bay
The Pie Factory - Largo Florida and Mike's Pies, per Tampa Bay Times
- Washington, DC
Henry's Soul Cafe and Blue Duck Tavern, per Eater DC
The West
- Albuquerque
Las Golondrinas Pie Company and Flying Star Cafe, per Albuquerque Journal
- Denver
Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St. and Granny Scott's Pie Shop, per 5280
- Honolulu
Anna Miller's Restaurant and Hawaiian Pie Company, per Honolulu Magazine
- Las Vegas
Jerry's Nugget Casino and Emeril's New Orleans Fish House, per Eater Vegas
- Los Angeles
The Apple Pan and Pie 'n Burger, per The Infatuation
- Phoenix
Little Miss BBQ-University and Buck & Rider Phoenix, per PHOENIX magazine
- Portland, OR
Lauretta Jean's and Banning's Restaurant & Pie House, per Portland Monthly
- Sacramento
Frank Fat's and Rick's Dessert Diner, per Sactown Magazine
- Salt Lake City
Pie Fight and The Dodo Restaurant, per Salt Lake Magazine
- San Diego
San Diego Chicken Pie Shop and Pop Pie Co., per San Diego Magazine
- Santa Fe
Harry's Roadhouse and Tune-Up Café, per Santa Fe New Mexican (Pasatiempo)
- Seattle
Simply Soulful and Buddha Bruddah Seattle, per Seattle Met
- SF Bay Area
Lois The Pie Queen and Heidi's Pies Restaurant, per San Francisco Chronicle
- Tucson
Gus Balon's Restaurant and Ajo Cafe, per Tucson Foodie